9 December 1999

THE TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION - 

Year End Summary

AMNESTY
At the moment the Truth and Reconciliation Commission is dealing with the
last leg of its work, the Amnesty applications. The TRC had three
components namely Human Rights Violation Committee, Reparation and
Rehabilitation Committee and The Amnesty Committee.

One of the reasons for the TRC's planned extension during the year 2000
is that all amnesty applications have not yet been finalised and have to
be processed. The Commission wishes to inform members of the public the
status of the amnesty applications as at November 15, 1999.

Finalised Amnesty Applications                     Decisions
Amnesty granted                                                568
Amnesty refused                                                5287
Amnesty partly refused/partly granted                 21
Amnesty Applications withdrawn                        161
Decision outstanding                                           272
TOTAL                                                             6037


Outstanding
Chamber matters 311
Hearable matters 347
Scheduled for hearings 157
TOTAL 815

From the above statistics the following can be noted:
* The Amnesty Committee have dealt with 91% of all applications received,
compared to the 70% at the end of 1998.
* It is estimated that only 5% of amnesty applications received, still
need to be scheduled for a public hearing.
* These statistics should be compared to those of June 1997 when only 20%
of all applications had been dealt with.
* Originally 2500 of the total number of applications received had been
identified as matters that had to be heard at public hearings. During
1996, 70 applications were scheduled to appear before the Amnesty
Committee, 200 during 1997, 720 during 1998 and approximately 1204 during
1999.
* This means that approximately 300 applications may still need to appear
before the Amnesty Committee. Although the Amnesty Committee has lost 6 of
its members during the course of 1999, it has managed to hear 90% more
applications than in 1998.

BREAKDOWN AS PER POLITICAL AFFILIATION

Political Affiliation Granted Partly Granted/Partly Refused  Refused  Total
ANC  383  2  167  552
AWB  56  0  23 79
IFP  28  0  20  48
NP 1  0  0  1
PAC 82  0  24  106
Security Forces  124  10  29  163

The above statistical information shows that both staff preparing and
presenting the amnesty applications as well as The Amnesty Committee
dealing with the applications, have increased their productivity
enormously.

FINALISATION OF AMNESTY PROCESS:
In the absence of unforeseen circumstances, The Amnesty Committee is on
track to finalise all hearable applications by end of March 2000 and to
submit a final Amnesty Report to the President by end of June 2000. The
objective is to use the months of April, May and June to deal with any
specific applications that may require attention, to finalise the audit of
all applications and to certify that all have been dealt with according
the Act.

REPARATION AND REHABILITATION COMMITTEE
The main focus of the committee's work since June 1998 has been on
implementation of interim reparation and matters relating to long term
policy development. To date, the number of completed and assessed
applications for reparations sent to the President Fund is 9165.

The President Fund has processed 4608 of the 9165 applications received
from the Committee. This represents the expenditure of R15,815,317.00. The
major component of the interim reparation recommendations received from
the Committee is the service recommendation, the President's Fund informs
the victim of what services has been recommended and refer them to a
relevant department.

To date the following referrals have been made by regions, to the
following services.

Province  Education  Housing  Employment Physical Health Mental Health  Welfare
Gauteng  647 181 75 688 1189 692
Eastern Cape   142 77  42  350  493  270
Northern Cape       12 0 1 31 28 9
Free State  23  18  5   42 53  26
North. Province  8  22  2  16  32  18
Mpumalanga       40 35 2 48 88 53
North West       13 1 2 31 31 14
Western Cape       156 76 41 206 214 133
KwaZulu Natal       1101 1295 31 1197 1772 1159


RECOMMENDATIONS
The Reparation and Rehabilitation Committee has held numerous discussions
with the Inter Ministerial Committee on reparations, the Premiers of the
nine provinces, as well as the Director Generals of the relevant
Ministries. The purpose of these discussions was to create an awareness
and understanding of the long term nature of reparations or victims/
survivors as found in the reparation policy.

Most recently the Committee has focused their efforts to communicate the
pressing need to establish a process within government which lead to the
formation of reparation co-ordinating structure at local and national
levels. This structure would be responsible for implementation of a long
term reparation process, and serve as the responsibility for all
outstanding reparations e.g. community, symbolic, administrative and
legal, following the life of the Reparations Committee.

Given the emerging picture of the survivors needs, it is apparent that
some are dire, life threatening, and cannot be met through a generalised
reconstruction and development programme. The attempt to facilitate the
reparations process from the TRC offices and President's Fund, when all
the service resources are within government department has not been
satisfactory, and has happened as a result of the absence of such a
structure.

An ideal structure would be one similar the Inter Ministerial Committee
for the children at risk initiated by government in 1995 or the current
Youth Commission Structure. As with this structure, it will be essential
for this structure to mandate the involvement of representatives of
relevant Ministries, in consultation with NGO's, Victim group, the
private, and other interested parties. The key principal is that the
reparation office should have powers to enforce co-operation from all the
Ministries.

It is essential that the proposed co-ordinating structure is located
within government as from the beginning of December 1999, so as to allow
government officials time to master information related to the reparation
process before the end of March 2000, when the committee intends to close
down its operations.

HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATION COMMITTEE
The Human Rights Violations Committee identified at the end of October
1998, the following outstanding tasks:

* The completion of findings in respect of victims and the gross human
rights violations they have suffered;
* The national audit of the more then 5000 negative findings made at
regional level;
* The establishment of an Appeal mechanism to deal with the negative
findings that had been confirmed at a national level;
* The finalisation of ˇ§Out of the Shadowsˇ¨, the ˇ§popularˇ¨ edition of
the Truth Commission report;
* The finalisation of the ˇ§Victims Volumeˇ¨, which would contain a
summary on each victim.
* The Committee had also undertaken to furnish the Minister with three
additional reports, i.e. 
                    * an exhumation report which would identify outstanding exhumations;
                    * a report on disappearances which would detail all disappearances
                    reported to the Commission and classify then into classic abductions,
                    missing in combat, disappearances in exile and missing persons;
                     * a report on combatants.

The Committee in the course and scope of its work in January and February
1999, identified that the database would need to be audited to ensure that
proper summaries could be written for each victim and to prevent the
possibility of multiple payments to reparation beneficiaries. The
transfer of assets and records from the regional offices of the TRC to
the National office has also engendered a certain degree of chaos. A
database audit team was appointed in March 1999 to begin the clean up and
began work in April 1999. They completed their work in November 1999.

As at the 1st December 1999, the Commission has completed all outstanding
victims findings. In addition the national internal audit of negative
findings has been completed. This has resulted in the confirmation of
approximately 1500 negative findings which include those out of mandate,
those not considered to be political and those with insufficient
information to make such a finding. The communication of negative
findings to victims is receiving a great deal of attention from the
commission to ensure that it is handled in the most sensitive and humane
manner. The Commission is also considering the setting up of a special
victims' line to deal with the queries that will be generated through the
communication to victims.

The Commission is still receiving applications from victims' groups that
they be considered for reparation.

The "Popular Edition" was completed in September 1999 and was ready to go
into print. However, the consensus within the Amnesty Committee is that
it should be held back to allow the current work being done by the
commission to be reflected in the Popular version. This will in all
probability mean publication in June 2000.

The Summary writing project began work in October 1999. Already 50% of
the summaries have been written and are ready for the first round of
editing. It is envisaged that the vast majority will be edited by
February 1999. It is envisage that this Volume will be published with the
codicil to the final report. The remaining reports will be completed in
February 1999.

The Commission is of the view that discussions need to begin with
government on who will take over the outstanding work of the HRV committee
particularly on an Appeals process. Presently the Commission deals with a
vast amount of queries from victims and government will need to take this
on boards as well. 

LEGAL ASSISTANCE PROGRAMME
The TRC is empowered in terms of the provisions of section 34(3) of the
Act 34 of 1995 to appoint a legal representative at a prescribed tariff to
appear on behalf of any person. The commission realised at the beginning
of the year that the TRC appeared to be footing the bill for virtually all
categories of persons appearing before the Amnesty Committee whether they
were victims, applicants, implicated persons or witnesses.

As a result hereof the Commission investigated the situation and
discovered that approximately R327 806.23 had been paid on the TRC's
behalf by the Legal Aid Board to amnesty applicants who were members of
the various liberation movements. In terms of paragraph 3(5) of the
submission of the Minister of Justice to the Executive Deputy President,
such members of liberation movements could be assisted by the State
Attorney in obtaining funding legal assistance.

The TRC and the Office of the State Attorney in Pretoria agreed that in
future such liberation forces members including IFP, Rightwing Groups
would be assisted by the State Attorney. The State Attorney agreed to
refund the TRC the amount which had been paid on behalf of liberation
forces applicants for the last financial year.

PAYMENT TO LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES
Payments by the TRC to legal practitioners is strictly in accordance with
the tariff which is prescribed in the Regulations Prescribing Tariff of
fees. In exceptional cases and upon application to the National Legal
Officer and after consultation with the Amnesty Evidence Leader a higher
daily appearance or preparation fee may be justified.

LEGAL AID BOARD MATTERS
During August 1999, the Amnesty Committee resolved to terminate the
mandate of the Legal Aid Board and gave that responsibility to the TRC's
Legal Department.