SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA

PIC

Judgments 2007

back

All documents are in pdf PDF format and require Acrobat Reader to open.

(*) Case Correction

  Citation & Summary
Delivered
174

Allianz Insurance Ltd v RHI Refractories Africa (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 174 (RSA) 616/06*

03 Dec
173

Le Roux v Hon Magistrate Mr Viana [2007] SCA 173 (RSA) 494/06

30 Nov
172
Menqa & Another v Markom & Others [2007] SCA 172 (RSA) 604/06
30 Nov
171

Whitehead v The State [2007] SCA 171 (RSA) 197/07 *

30 Nov
170

Qualidental Laboratories v Heritage Western Cape [2007] SCA 170 (RSA) 647/06

30 Nov
169

DPP, Western Cape v Killian [2007] SCA 169 (RSA) 690/06*

30 Nov
168

Shaikh v Standard Bank [2007] SCA 168 (RSA) 27/07

29 Nov
167

Allaclas Investments (Pty) Ltd & Another v Milnerton Golf Club & Others [2007] 167 SCA (RSA) 673/06

29 Nov
166

Aartappel Koöperasie Bpk v PriceWaterhouseCoopers [2007] SCA 166 (RSA) 055/07

29 Nov
165

Millennium Waste Management v Chairperson Tender Board [2007] SCA 165 (RSA) 31/07

29 Nov
164

Hammond v State [2007] SCA 164 (RSA) 320/07

29 Nov
163

Hosmed Medical Aid Scheme v Thebe Ya Bophelo Healthcare [2007] SCA 163 (RSA) 015/07

29 Nov
162

Be Bop a Lula v Kingtex [2007] SCA 162 (RSA) 042/07*

29 Nov
161
Bezuidenhout v Director of Public Prosecutions [2007] SCA 161 (RSA) 175/07
29 Nov
160

Carmel Trading Company Limited v CSARS [2007] SCA 160 (RSA) 447/07

29 Nov
159

Chagi v Special Investigating Unit [2007] SCA 159 (RSA) 89/07

29 Nov
158

L Venter obo A Klaasen v Road Accident Fund [2007] SCA 158 (RSA) 660/2006

29 Nov
157

Shabalala v Metrorail [2007] SCA 157 (RSA) 062/07

28 Nov
156

Price v Minister of Correctional Services [2007] SCA 156 (RSA) 511/2006

28 Nov
155

MEC for Education v Strauss [2007] SCA 155 (RSA) 640/06

28 Nov
154

Cecil Nurse (Pty) Ltd v Nkola [2007] SCA 154 (RSA) 176/2006

28 Nov
153

Minister of Land Affairs and Agriculture v D & F Wevell Trust [2007] SCA 153 (RSA) 171/06

28 Nov
152

Body Corporate of Greenacres v Greenacres Unit 17 CC [2007] SCA 152 (RSA) 521/06*

28 Nov
151

Appels v The State [2007] SCA 151 (RSA) 303/07

28 Nov
150

NDPP v Vermaak [2007] SCA 150 (RSA) 368/06

28 Nov
149

DG Department of Home Affairs v Mavericks Revue CC [2007] SCA 149 (RSA) 576/06

28 Nov
148

Road Accident Fund v Rampukar/Road Accident Fund v Gumede [2007] SCA 148 (RSA) 543/06

28 Nov
147

CSARS v Airworld CC [2007] SCA 147 (RSA) 672/2006

26 Nov
146

Volcano Agroscience (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Agriculture [2007] SCA 146 (RSA) 641/2006

26 Nov
145

PGB Boerdery Beleggings (EdMedia Summary) Bpk v Somerville 62 (EdMedia Summary) Bpk [2007] SCA 145 (RSA) 36/07 - Only in Afrikaans

26 Nov
144
Bid Industrial Holdings v Strang [2007] SCA 144 (RSA) 615/2006
23 Nov
143

Lufuno Mphaphuli & Associates v Andrews [2007] SCA 143 (RSA) 434/2006

22 Nov
142

Eley v Lynn & Main Inc [2007] SCA 142 (RSA) 614/2006

22 Nov
141

Intramed v Standard Bank [2007] SCA 141 (RSA) 629/2006

20 Nov
140

Nortje v Die Staat [2007] SCA 140 (RSA) 600/06 *Only in Afrikaans

09 Nov
139

Minister of Safety & Security v Bennett [2007] SCA 139 (RSA) 302/06

08 Nov
138

NDPP v Mahomed [2007] SCA 138 (RSA) 596/05

08 Nov
137

NDPP v Zuma & Hulley [2007] SCA 137 (RSA) 639/06

08 Nov
136

Thint v NDPP [20074] SCA 136 (RSA) 671/06

08 Nov
135

JG Zuma and Thint v NDPP [2007] SCA 135 (RSA) 232/2007

08 Nov
134

Pakane v The State [2007] SCA 134 (RSA) 43/2007 *

28 Sep
133

Stalwo v Wary Holdings [2007] SCA 133 (RSA) 377/2006

28 Sep
132

Hack Stupel & Ross v Kgang [2007] SCA 132 (RSA) 560/2006

28 Sep
131

KwaZulu CMS Monitoring Systems v KZN Gambling Board [2007] SCA 131 (RSA) 470/2006

28 Sep
130

Minister of Local Government, Housing & Traditional Affairs (KwaZulu-Natal) v Umlambo Trading 29 CC [2007] SCA 130 (RSA) 487/2006

28 Sep
129

Mngomezulu v NDPP [2007] SCA 129 (RSA) 338/2006

28 Sep
128

Tetra Mobile Radio v MEC, Department of Works [2007] SCA 128 (RSA) 482/2006

28 Sep
127

Scott-Crossley v S [2007] SCA 127 (RSA) 677/2006

28 Sep
126

Just Names Properties v Fourie [2007] SCA 126 (RSA) 324/2006

28 Sep
125

Dissel v The State [2007] SCA 125 (RSA) 598/2006

28 Sep
124

Van Niekerk v Favel [2007] SCA 124 (RSA) 627/2006

27 Sep
123

Vari-Deals 101 (Pty) Ltd v Sunsmart Products (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 123 (RSA) 503/2006

27 Sep
122

Legh v Nungu Trading 353 [2007] SCA 122 (RSA) 03/2007

27 Sep
121
Republican Press v CEPPWAWU [2007] SCA 121 (RSA) 218/2006 *
27 Sep
120
Raol Investments v Madlala [2007] SCA 120 (RSA) 461/2006
27 Sep
119

Mngqibisa v The State [2007] SCA 119 (RSA) 75/2007

27 Sep
118

Progress Office Machines v SARS [2007] SCA 118 (RSA) 532/2006*

25 Sep
117

Strydom v Liebenberg [2007] SCA 117 (RSA) 293/2006

25 Sep
116
Van Niekerk v Van Niekerk [2007] SCA 116 (RSA) 460/2006
21 Sep
115

The Olympic Countess [2007] SCA 115 (RSA) 242/2006

21 Sep
114

Road Accident Fund v Ngubane [2007] SCA 114 (RSA) 585/2006

21 Sep
113

Fhetani v The State [2007] SCA 113 (RSA) 158/2007

21 Sep
112

Lombard Insurance v City of Cape Town [2007] SCA 112 (RSA) 441/2006

21 Sep
111

Kebble v Minister of Water Affairs [2007] SCA 111 (RSA) 530/2006

21 Sep
110

Mabuza v The State [2007] SCA 110 (RSA) 174/2006

20 Sep
109

Van Zyl v Government of RSA [2007] SCA 109 (RSA) 170/2006

20 Sep
108
Wessels v Pretorius [2007] SCA 108 (RSA) 418/2006
20 Sep
107
Exdev v Yeoman Properties [2007] SCA 107 (RSA) 314/2006
19 Sep
106
Schwartz NO v Pike [2007] SCA 106 (RSA) 668/2006
19 Sep
105
CSARS v Trend Finance (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 105 (RSA) 162/2006 (order)
19 Sep
104

Webtrade v Van der Schyff [2007] SCA 104 (RSA) 589/2006*

17 Sep
103

SA Breweries v Shoprite Holdings [2007] SCA 103 (RSA) 476/2006

14 Sep
102

Naidoo v The State [2007] SCA 102 (RSA) 433/2006

14 Sep
101
The Trustees, Bus Industry Restructuring Fund v Break Through Investments [2007] SCA 101 (RSA) 397/2006
14 Sep
100

CSARS v The Baking Tin [2007] SCA 100 (RSA) 431/2006

14 Sep
99

CSARS v Brummeria Renaissance (Pty)Ltd [2007] SCA 99 (RSA) 391/2006

13 Sep
98
Bridges v The State [2007] SCA 98 (RSA) 478/2007
12 Sep
97
MTN Service Provider v Afro Call [2007] SCA 97 (RSA) 370/2006
12 Sep
96

Commercial Auto Glass (Pty) Ltd v BMW AG [2007] SCA 96 (RSA) 331/2006

07 Sep
95

Barnett v Minister of Land Affairs [2007] SCA 95 (RSA) 304/2006

06 Sep
94

Blignaut v The State [2007] SCA 94 (RSA) 588/2006

30 Aug
93
Crossberg v S [2007] SCA 93 (RSA) 439/2007
22 Aug
92

Minister of Justice & Constitutional Development v Zealand [2007] SCA 92 (RSA) 387/2006

20 Jun
91

Balkwell v The State [2007] SCA 91 (RSA) 315/2006

20 Jun
90
Radio Pretoria v The Independent Communications Authority of South Africa [2007] SCA 90 (RSA) 296/2006
08 Jun
89

Mutual & Federal v Da Costa [2007] SCA 89 (RSA) 243/2006

06 Jun
88

Central Authority v Houwert [2007] SCA 88 (RSA) 262/2006

04 Jun
87

De Gree v Webb [2007] SCA 87 (RSA) 379/2006

01 Jun
86

Constantaras v BCE Foodservice Equipment [2007] SCA 86 (RSA) 208/2006*

01 Jun
85
Lodhi 2 Properties v Bondev [2007] SCA 85 (RSA) 128/2006
01 Jun
84

Agrico Masjinerie v Swiers [2007] SCA 84 (RSA) 399/2006

01 Jun
83

Bell v RAF [2007] SCA 83 (RSA) 121/2006*

01 Jun
82

Singh v NDPP [2007] SCA 82 (RSA) 268/2006

01 Jun
81
Dlepu v The State [2007] SCA 81 (RSA) 567/2006
01 Jun
80

Bowring NO v Vrededorp Properties CC [2007] SCA 80 (RSA) 271/2006

31 May
79

Boxer Superstores Mthatha v Mbenya [2007] SCA 79 (RSA) 97/2006

31 May
78

RAF v Grobler [2007] SCA 78 (RSA) 96/2006

31 May
77

Pretorius NO v Stanlib Wealth Management Ltd [2007] SCA 77 (RSA) 380/2006

31 May
76

Vhengani v The State [2007] SCA 76 (RSA) 444/2006

31 May
75

Minister of Defence v Dunn [2007] SCA 75 (RSA)131/2006*

31 May
74
Kriel v Beukes [2007] SCA 74 (RSA) 346/2006
31 May
73

Botha v Giyose t/a Paragon Fisheries [2007] SCA 73 (RSA) 447/2006

31 May
72

Amplats Management Services (Pty) Ltd v Van Jaarsveld [2007] SCA 72 (RSA) 269/2006

31 May
71

MP Finance Group CC v CSARS [2007] SCA 71 (RSA) 41/2006

31 May
70

Tswelopele Non-Profit Organisation v City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality [2007] SCA 70 (RSA) 303/2006

30 May
69

Haakdoornbult Boerdery CC v Mphela [2007] SCA 69 (RSA) 553/2005*

30 May
68
Cohen v Lench [2007] SCA 68 (RSA) 139/2006
29 May
67

ABSA Bank Bpk v Du Preez; Beyplas EdMedia Summary Bpk [2007] SCA 67 (RSA) 343/2006

29 May
66

Pietermaritzburg SPCA v Peerbhai [2007] SCA 66 (RSA) 422/2006

29 May
65
Ramdeo v DPP [2007] SCA 65 (RSA) 650/2006
29 May
64

Van der Merwe v RAF [2007] SCA 64 (RSA) 179/2006

29 May
63

Chagi v Singisi Forest Products [2007] SCA 63 (RSA) 227/2006

29 May
62
Ethekwini Metropolitan Unicity Municipality v Pilco Investments CC [2007] SCA 62 (RSA) 320/2006
29 May
61

Citibank NA v Thandroyen Fruit Wholesalers CC [2007] SCA 61 (RSA) 287/2006

28 May
60

Merry Hill v Engelbrecht [2007] SCA 60 (RSA) 323/2006

24 May
59

CSARS v Trend Finance (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 59 (RSA) 162/2006

23 May
58

Mamushe v The State [2007] SCA 58 (RSA) 53/2004

18 May
57

Road Accident Fund v Monjane [2007] SCA 57 (RSA) 295/2006

18 May
56

Midi Television (Pty) Ltd v DPP [2007] SCA 56 (RSA) 100/2006

18 May
55

ER24 Holdings v Smith NO [2007] SCA 55 (RSA) 392/2006

18 May
54
Tao Ying Metal Industries v Pooe NO [2007] SCA 54 (RSA) 222/2006*
18 May
53

Verimark (Pty) Ltd v BMW AG [2007] SCA 53 (RSA) 250/2006

17 May
52

Old Mutual v Gumbi [2007] SCA 52 (RSA) 211/2006*

17 May
51

Nel v The State [2007] SCA 51 (RSA) 318/2006

11 May
50

Sunsmart v Flag and Flagpole Industries [2007] SCA 50 (RSA) 072/2006

03 Apr
49

Joint Municipal Fund v LJ Grobler [2007] SCA 49 (RSA) 183/2006

30 Mar
48

Registrar of Pension Funds v B Angus NO [2007] SCA 48 (RSA) 677/2005

30 Mar
47

Potgieter v Potgieter [2007] SCA 47 (RSA) 215/2006

30 Mar
46

Scott-Crossley v The State [2007] SCA 46 (RSA) 100/2007

29 Mar
45*

Gutsche Family Investments v Mettle Equity Group [2007] SCA 45 (RSA) 133/2006

29 Mar
44*

The Chairpersons’ Association v Minister of Arts and Culture [2007] SCA 44 (RSA) 025/2006

29 Mar
43

Ghersi v Tiber Developments (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 43 (RSA) 084/2006

29 Mar
42

Du Plessis v Die Staat [2007] 42 (RSA) 316/2006

29 Mar
41

Jochen Kofahl v S L Keiley [2007] SCA 41 (RSA) 348/2006

29 Mar
40

Smith v The State [2007] SCA 40 (RSA) 046/2006

28 Mar
39

Mlenze v The State [2007] SCA 39 (RSA) 569/2006

28 Mar
38

eThekwini Municipality v Tsogo Sun Kwazulu-Natal [2007] SCA 38 (RSA) 086/2006

28 Mar
37*

HTF Developers (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Environmental Affairs & Tourism [2007] SCA 37 (RSA) 337/2006

28 Mar
36

Wypkema v Lubbe [2007]SCA 36 (RSA)138/2006

28 Mar
35

Clearing Agents v MEC Transport [2007] SCA 35 (RSA) 659/2005

28 Mar
34

S v Tandwa [2007] SCA 34 (RSA) 538/2006

28 Mar
33

Haslam v The State [2007] SCA 33 (RSA) 297/2006

28 Mar
32

McCarthy Ltd v Gore NO [2007] SCA 32 (RSA) 163/2006

28 Mar
31

McGregor v City of Johannesburg [2007] SCA 31 (RSA) 89/2006

28 Mar
30

Dendy v University of the Witwatersrand [2007] SCA 30 (RSA) 597/2005

28 Mar
29

Minister of Safety and Security v Ndniso [2007] SCA 29 (RSA) 286/2006

27 Mar
28

City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality v RPM Bricks (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 28 (RSA) 177/2006

27 Mar
27

Moodley v Nedcor [2007] SCA 27 (RSA) 085/2006

27 Mar
26

Minister of Social Development v Phoenix Cash & Carry [2007] SCA 26 (RSA) 189/2006 & 244/2006

26 Mar
25

City of Johannesburg v Rand Properties (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 25 (RSA) 253/2006

26 Mar
24

Clipsal Australia (Pty) Ltd v Trust Electrical Wholesalers [2007] SCA 24 (RSA) 125/2006

23 Mar
23

Janse van Rensburg v NDPP [2007] SCA 23 (RSA) 75/2006

23 Mar
22
CSARS, Gauteng West v Levue Investments (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 22 (RSA) 537/2006
23 Mar
21

Minister of Safety and Security v Mohofe [2007] SCA 21 (RSA) 200/2006

23 Mar
20
Assured Freight Services (Pty) Ltd v Comair Ltd [2007] SCA 20 (RSA) 73/2006
23 Mar
19

Smith v Porritt [2007] SCA 19 (RSA) 536/2005

23 Mar
18

Senwes v Van Heerden & Sons [2007] SCA 18 (RSA) 601/2005

23 Mar
17

Wessels v Die Meester [2007] SCA 17 (RSA) 216/2006

23 Mar
16

Van der Berg v General Council of the Bar [2007] SCA 16 (RSA) 270/2006

22 Mar
15

Propfokus 49 (Pty) Ltd v Wenhandel (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 15 (RSA) 103/2006

20 Mar
14

Cornick & Kinnear v The State [2007] SCA 14 (RSA) 409/2006

20 Mar
13

Imperial Group (Pty) Ltd v NCS Resins (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 13 (RSA) 197/2006

20 Mar
12

MSC Spain [2007] SCA 12 (RSA) 204/2006

20 Mar
11

Mngomezulu v National Director of Public Prosecutions [2007] SCA 11 (RSA) 446/05

16 Mar
10

Lubbe NO v Millennium Style [2007] SCA 10 (RSA) 69/2006*

16 Mar
9

PCL Consulting (Pty) Ltd v Tresso Trading 119 (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 9 (RSA) 98/2006

15 Mar
8

Dream Supreme Properties 11CC v Nedcor Bank [2007] SCA 8 (RSA) 490/2005

13 Mar
7

BPSA (Pty) Ltd v CSARS [2007] SCA 7 (RSA) 60/2006

13 Mar
6

Insamcor v Dorbyl [2007] SCA 6 (RSA) 63/2006 & 319/2006

12 Mar
5
Jointwo Holdings (Pty) ltd v Old Mutual Life Assurance Company (SA) Ltd [2007] SCA 5 (RSA) 115/2006
08 Mar
4

BOE Bank v The Grange Timber Farming Co (Pty) Ltd [2007] SCA 4 (RSA) 252/2006

05 Mar
3

Lewis v S [2007] SCA 3 (RSA) 610/06

02 Mar
2
Grütter v Lombard [2007] SCA 2 (RSA) 628/05
20 Feb
1

CDA Boerdery (EdMedia Summary) Bpk and Others v The Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality and Others [2007] SCA 1 (RSA) 526/05

06 Feb
   
top