SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA

PIC

Judgments 2006

back

All documents are in pdf PDF format and require Acrobat Reader to open.

(*) Case Correction

  Citation & Summary
Delivered
175
Govender v The State [2006] SCA 175 (RSA) 047/06
15 Dec
174

Nwamitwa Shilubana v Nwamitwa [2006] SCA 174 (RSA) 11/05

01 Dec
173

Director of Public Prosecutions: Transvaal v SI Basson [2006] SCA 173 (RSA) 261/2006

01 Dec
172

Unilever Bestfoods Robertsons v Soomar [2006] SCA 172 (RSA) 613/05

01 Dec
171
DH Swanepoel v The State [2006] SCA 171 (RSA) 042/2006
01 Dec
170

De Villiers v Potgieter [2006] SCA 170 (RSA) 611/05

01 Dec
169

Dippenaar v The State [2006] SCA 169 (RSA) 173/06

01 Dec
168

Carter v S [2006] SCA 168 (RSA) 535/2006

01 Dec
167

Nkomo v The State [2006] SCA 167 RSA 160/2000

01 Dec
166

Engelbrecht and Van der Walt NNO v Senwes 2006 SCA 166 (RSA) 631/2005

30 Nov
165

Farocean Marine v Minister of Trade and Industry 2006 SCA 165 (RSA) 614/2005

30 Nov
164

Reddy v Siemens [2006] SCA 164 (RSA) 251/06

30 Nov
163

Claase v Information Officer of South African Airways [2006] SCA 163 (RSA) 39/2006

30 Nov
162

Gowar Investments v Section 3 Dolphin Coast and Cameron [2006] SCA 162 (RSA) 474/05

30 Nov
161

Meter NO v Geo Parkes & Son (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 161 (RSA) 590/05

30 Nov
160

Yarram Trading v Absa [2006] SCA 160 (RSA) 625/05

30 Nov
159

Oosthuizen v The State [2006] SCA 159 (RSA) 313/06

30 Nov
158

Ndlovu v The State [2006] SCA 158 (RSA) 380/03

30 Nov
157
Legal Aid Board and Jordaan [2006] SCA 157 (RSA) 228/06
30 Nov
156

Mano et Mano v Nationwide Airlines (Pty) Ltd and Others [2006] SCA 156 (RSA) 606/05

30 Nov
155

Heslop v S [2006] SCA 155 (RSA) 216/05A

30 Nov
154
Shaik & others v Director for Public Prosecutions, KwaZulu Natal [2006] SCA 154 (RSA) 148/06
30 Nov
153
Odgers v De Gersigny [2006] SCA 153 (RSA) 032/06
30 Nov
152

Thabakholo Landscaping v Hydromulch [2006] SCA 152 (RSA) 496/05

30 Nov
151

S v Tembani [2006] SCA 151 (RSA) 116/02

30 Nov
150

SA Tourism v Pasis [2006] SCA 150 RSA 102/06

29 Nov
149

Mngomezulu v Van den Heever [2006] SCA 149 (RSA) 626/2005

29 Nov
148

Richman v Ben-Tovim [2006] SCA 148 (RSA) 674/2005

29 Nov
147

Mutual and Federal v Chemalum 2006 SCA 147 (RSA) 683/05

29 Nov
146

Anglo Operations v Sandhurst [2006] SCA 146 (RSA) 634/05

29 Nov
145
Stevens v CSARS [2006] SCA 145 (RSA) 641/05
28 Nov
144

Van Deventer v Van Deventer [2006] SCA 144 (RSA) 88/06

24 Nov
143

Desert Palace Hotel Resort v Northern Cape Gambling Board [2006] SCA 143 (RSA) 630/05

24 Nov
142

Jacobs v Braaff [2006] SCA 142 (RSA) 603/2005

24 Nov
141

Monyane and Others v The State [2006] SCA 141 (RSA) 160/01

23 Nov
140
Nel v Metequity Ltd [2006] SCA 140 (RSA) 658/05
22 Nov
139

Telcordia Technologies Inc v Telkom SA [2006] 139 SCA (RSA) 26/05

22 Nov
138

Northwest Provincial Government v Tswaing Consulting CC [2006] SCA 138 (RSA) 190/2005

21 Nov
137
Hyperception v Waterhouse [2006] SCA 137 (RSA) 93/06
21 Nov
136
Pogostich v McLeod [2006] SCA 136 (RSA) 247/06
21 Nov
135

National Director of Public Prosecutions v Van Staden [2006] SCA 135 (RSA) 531/2005

09 Nov
134

Shaik v The State (1) [2006] SCA 134 (RSA) 62/06

06 Nov
134

Shaik v The State (2) [2006] SCA 134 (RSA) 248/06

06 Nov
133
Sikhosana v S [2006] SCA 133 (RSA) 098/05
03 Nov
132
The State v Mabena [2006] SCA 132 (RSA) 373/06
17 Oct
131

Transnet Limited v PNN Chirwa [2006] SCA 131 (RSA) 024/2005

29 Sep
130

Drifters Adventure Tours v Hircock [2006] SCA 130 (RSA) 602/2005

29 Sep
129

Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority v Anglo Platinum Management Services Ltd [2006] SCA 129 (RSA) 588/05

29 Sep
128

Automotive Tooling SysteMedia Summary v Wilkens [2006] SCA 128 (RSA) 581/05

28 Sep
127

Crown Chickens (Pty) Ltd v Rieck [2006] SCA 127 (RSA) 483/05

28 Sep
126

Sithole v The State [2006] SCA 126 (RSA) 54/06

28 Sep
125

Prosch v Impala Water Users’ Association [2006] SCA 125 (RSA) 428/05

28 Sep
124

Popela Community & Others v Goedgelegen Tropical Fruits (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 124 (RSA) 441/05

28 Sep
123

Road Accident Fund v Smith [2006] SCA 123 (RSA) 334/05

28 Sep
122

Garrido v DPP [2006] SCA 122 (RSA) 177/05

28 Sep
121

Government Employees Pension Fund v Buitendag [2006] SCA 121 (RSA) 550/05

27 Sep
120

DPP, Transvaal v Mtshweni [2006] SCA 120 (RSA) 52/06

27 Sep
119

Commissioner, SA Revenue Service v Motion Vehicle Wholesalers [2006] SCA 119 (RSA) 509/05

26 Sep
118

Commissioner, SA Revenue Service v Komatsu SA (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 118 (RSA) 448/05

26 Sep
117

Minister of Safety & Security v N Folo & 2 Others [2006] SCA 117 (RSA) 435/05

26 Sep
116

Heneways Freight Services v Klaus Grogor [2006] SCA 116 (RSA) 387/2004

26 Sep
115

Rustenburg Platinum Mines Ltd v CCMA [2006] SCA 115 (RSA) 598/05

26 Sep
114
De Jager, A M v The State [2006] SCA 114 (RSA) 53/06
26 Sep
113

Plit v Imperial Bank Ltd [2006] SCA 113 RSA 70/05

26 Sep
112

Nedcor Bank v Rundle [2006] SCA 112 RSA 455/05

26 Sep
111

Relyant Trading (Pty) Ltd v Shongwe [2006] SCA 111 RSA 472/05

26 Sep
110
Dlamini and another v The State [2006] SCA 110 (RSA) 175/01
26 Sep
109
Fuel Retailers Association v DG, Environmental Management, Mpumalanga [2006] SCA 109 RSA 530/05
22 Sep
108
Ngcina v The State [2006] SCA 108 (RSA) 201/06
22 Sep
107

Howick District Landowners Association v uMngeni Municipality [2006] SCA 107 (RSA) 423/05

21 Sep
106

Allers v Fourie [2006] SCA 106 (RSA) 491/2005

21 Sep
105

Sassman v The State [2006] SCA 105 (RSA) 78/06

20 Sep
104
Burger v Rand Water Board [2006] SCA 104 (RSA) 392/05
20 Sep
103

Madzunye v Road Accident Fund [2006] SCA 103 (RSA) 017/2006

20 Sep
102
Aventura Ltd v Jackson N.O. [2006] SCA 102 (RSA) 290/05
15 Sep
101

The Minister of Water Affairs and Forestry and Others v Durr and Others [2006] SCA 101 (RSA) 278/05

14 Sep
100

Hartley v Pyramid Freight (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 100 (RSA) 498/05

14 Sep
99

Klopper v Schreuder [2006] SCA 99 (RSA) 499/05

12 Sep
98

First Rand Ltd v Scholtz NO [2006] SCA 98 RSA 373/05

11 Sep
97

Minister of Finance v Gore NO [2006] SCA 97 (RSA) 230/2006

08 Sep
96

MEC for Public Works, Roads and Transport v Esterhuizen [2006] SCA 96 (RSA) 488/05

07 Sep
95
Walker v Redhouse [2006] SCA 95 (RSA) 393/05
31 Aug
94

Mittalsteel SA Ltd v Hlatshwayo [2006] SCA 94 (RSA) 326/05

31 Aug
93

City of Cape Town v Helderberg Park Development (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 93 RSA 429/05

31 Aug
92

Naylor v Jansen [2006] SCA 92 (RSA) 508/05

31 Aug
91
South African National Defence Union v Minister of Defence & Others [2006] SCA 91 (RSA) 307/05
31 Aug
90

Sandu & v Minister of Defence & Others [2006] SCA 90 (RSA) 306/05

31 Aug
89

SABC v Downer NO and Shaik [2006] SCA 89 (RSA) 435/06

24 Aug
88
De Leeuw v MEC LOCAL Government and Housing, Free State [2006] SCA 88 (RSA) 420/05
18 Aug
87

Society of Lloyd’s v Price; Society of Lloyd’s v Lee [2006] SCA 87 (RSA) 327/05

01 Jun
86

MV Spirit of Namibia [2006] SCA 86 RSA 33/06

01 Jun
85

Tsogo Sun Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Shan [2006] SCA 85 (RSA) 374/05

31 May
84
Truck and General Insurance Co Ltd v Verulam Fuel Distributors CC [2006] SCA 84 (RSA) 540/04
31 May
83

MEC: Welfare (KZN) v Machi [2006] SCA 83 (RSA) 333/05

31 May
82

Lourens NO v Impala Water Users Association [2006] SCA 82 (RSA) 534/2004

31 May
81

Legal Aid Board v Pretorius [2006] SCA 81 (RSA) 332/05

31 May
80

Rootman v The President of the Republic of South Africa [2006] SCA 80 RSA 016/06

31 May
79

Samsudin v De Villiers Berrange NO [2006] SCA 79 (RSA) 170/2005

31 May
78

De Beer v The State [2006] SCA 78 (RSA) 10/06

31 May
77

Saincic v Industro-Clean (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 77 (RSA) 229/05

31 May
76

Zola Kenneth Gunqisa and Others v The State [2006] SCA 76 (RSA) 504/2005

31 May
75

Melamed Finance v VOC Investments [2006] SCA 75 (RSA) 364/05

31 May
74

Mambo v The State [2006] SCA 74 (RSA) 143/01

31 May
73

MEC Public Works, Roads & Transport: Free State Provincial Government v Phuthanang Transport Service [2006] SCA 73 (RSA) 51/2005

31 May
72
Business Aviation Corporation v Rand Airport Holdings [2006] SCA 72 (RSA) 179/05
30 May
71
Sikhipha v State [2006] SCA 71 (RSA) 262/05
30 May
70
Makatu v State [2006] SCA 70 (RSA) 245/05
30 May
69
Impala Platinum v KLM [2006] SCA 69 (RSA) 315/05
30 May
68
Land Bank v The Master and others [2006] SCA 68 RSA 352/05
30 May
67
The Minister of Safety and Security v Seymour, D T [2006] SCA 67 (RSA) 295/05
30 May
66

Rasengani v The State [2006] SCA 66 (RSA) 008/04

29 May
65

Harmony Gold Mining Co Ltd v Regional Director: Free State, Department Water Affairs and Forestry [2006] SCA 65 (RSA) 269/05

29 May
64
Ralukukwe v S [2006] SCA 64 (RSA) 98/2005
26 May
63
Department of Public Works v M S Moos Construction CC [2006] SCA 63 (RSA) 401/05
25 May
62
Feldman v Migdin NO [2006] SCA 62 (RSA) 194/05
26 May
61
Thusukula Senatsi & Another v The State [2006] SCA 61 (RSA) 431/04
26 May
60

The Commissioner of South African Revenue Services v BP South Africa (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 60 (RSA) 92/05

25 May
59

Summerley v Law Society, Northern Provinces [2006] SCA 59 (RSA) 270/05

19 May
58
Cartoria Motor Industries v Swanepoel [2006] SCA 58 (RSA) 487/2005
19 May
57

Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism v George [2006] SCA 57 (RSA) 437/2005

18 May
56
Zanner v Director of Public Prosecutions [2006] SCA 56 (RSA) 107/05
03 Apr
55
South African Revenue Service v Hawker Air Services (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 55 (RSA) 379/05
31 Mar
54
Fakie v CCII SysteMedia Summary (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 54 (RSA) 653/2004
31 Mar
53
Steinberg v Lazard [2006] SCA 53 (RSA) 157/05
31 Mar
52
Masterspice (Pty) Ltd v Broszeit Investments CC [2006] SCA 52 (RSA) 252/05
31 Mar
51
Joubert v Die Benede Blyderivierwatergebruikersvereniging [2006] SCA 51 (RSA) 189/05
31 Mar
50
BOE Bank Limited v J J Bassage [2006] SCA 50 (RSA) 445/04
31 Mar
49
Bafana Finance Mabopane v Makwakwa [2006] SCA 49 (RSA) 475/04
30 Mar
48
Barloworld Capital Pty Ltd v Napier NO [2006] SCA 48 (RSA) 509/04
30 Mar
47
First National Bank v Duvenhage [2006] SCA 47 (RSA) 188/05
30 Mar
46
Member of the Executive Council: Welfare v Kate [2006] SCA 46 (RSA) 580/04
30 Mar
45
City of Johannesburg v Kaplan NO [2006] SCA 45 (RSA) 111/05
29 Mar
44
Muholi v State [2006] SCA 44 (RSA) 450/05
29 Mar
43
State v Saeed [2006] SCA 43 (RSA) 432/05
29 Mar
42
Coetzer v Die Staat [2006] SCA 42 (RSA) 255/05
29 Mar
41
Muller v The State [2006] SCA 41 (RSA) 236/05
29 Mar
40
Minister of Transport v Du Toit [2006] SCA 40 (RSA) 602/04
29 Mar
39
Haupt v Brewers Marketing Intelligence (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 39 (RSA) 118/05
29 Mar
38
Molimi v The State [2006] SCA 38 (RSA) 249/05
29 Mar
37
Law Society, Cape v Peter [2006] SCA 37 (RSA) 126/05 *
28 Mar
36
Gardner v Margo [2006] SCA 36 (RSA) 549/04
28 Mar
35
Basie Motors Bk t/a Boulevard Motors v Minister of Safety and Security [2006] SCA 35 (RSA) 135/05
28 Mar
34

MEC for Roads & Public Works v Intertrade Two (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 34 (RSA) 047/2005

27 Mar
33
De Swardt v House of Trucks [2006] SCA 33 (RSA) 143/05
27 Mar
32

Unitas Hospital v Van Wyk [2006] SCA 32 (RSA) 231/2005

27 Mar
31

D & H Piping SysteMedia Summary (Pty) Ltd v Trans Hex Group Ltd [2006] SCA 31 (RSA) 119/05

24 Mar
30

Thorpe v Trittenwein [2006] SCA 30 (RSA) 71/05

24 Mar
29

City of Johannesburg v Debbie Investments CC [2006] SCA 29 (RSA) 601/04

23 Mar
28

Gerber v The State [2006] SCA 28 (RSA) 353/2005

23 Mar
27

Tsung v Industrial Development Corp of SA Ltd [2006] SCA 27 (RSA) 79/05

23 Mar
26
Burris (Pty) Ltd t/a Service Electrical v Efstratios Moumtzis and Another [2006] SCA 26 (RSA) 192/05
23 Mar
25

Transnet Ltd v Tshabalala [2006] SCA 25 (RSA) 151/2005

22 Mar
24

Hirschowitz Flionis v Bartlett and Another [2006] SCA 24 (RSA) 546/04

22 Mar
23

Nonyane v The State [2006] SCA 23 (RSA) 256/05

20 Mar
22
Heslop v The State [2006] SCA 22 (RSA) 216/05
20 Mar
21
Sentraal-Suid Koöperasie Bpk v Bessemer Staalkonstruksie (EdMedia Summary) Bpk [2006] SCA 21 (RSA) 516/04
20 Mar
20

Marvanic Development (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Safety and Security [2006] SCA 20 (RSA) 232/05

20 Mar
19

Leo Manufacturing CC v Robor Industrial (Pty) Ltd t/a Robor Stewarts & Lloyds [2006] SCA 19 (RSA) 608/2004

20 Mar
18

Road Accident Fund v G S O Guedes [2006] SCA 18 (RSA) 611/2004

20 Mar
17

Truter v Deysel [2006] SCA 17 (RSA) 043/2005

17 Mar
16

Chenia & Sons CC v Lamé & Van Blerk [2006] SCA 16 (RSA) 303/05

17 Mar
15

S v Roslee [2006] SCA 15 (RSA) 296/05

17 Mar
14
Oos Vrystaat Kaap Bedryf Beperk v Van Aswegen [2006] SCA 14 (RSA) 54/05
17 Mar
13

Minister of Safety and Security v Luiters [2006] SCA 13 (RSA) 213/05

17 Mar
12

S Smith v RAF [2006] SCA 12 (RSA) 164/2005

17 Mar
11

National Director of Public Prosecutions v Mohunram [2006] SCA 11 (RSA) 173/05

17 Mar
10

South African Revenue Services v Desmonds Clearing and Forwarding Agents CC [2006] SCA 10 (RSA) 39/05

16 Mar
9

Sackstein NO v Proudfoot SA (Pty) Limited [2006] SCA 9 (RSA) 141/05

10 Mar
8

Bergkelder Bpk v Vredendal Koöp Wynmakery [2006] SCA 8 (RSA) 105/05

09 Mar
7

Botha v Botha [2006] SCA 7 (RSA) 393/04

09 Mar
6

S v Charzen [2006] SCA 6 (RSA) 344/05

09 Mar
5
Gagu v The State [2006] SCA 5 (RSA) 416/04
09 Mar
4
The Maize Board v Temple Albert Hart [2006] SCA 4 (RSA)248/05
07 Mar
3

R Green and Another v The State [2006] SCA 3 (RSA) 008/06

03 Mar
2

Hanekom v Builders Market Klerksdorp (Pty) Ltd [2006] SCA 2 (RSA) 63/05 *

02 Mar
1

National Sorghum Breweries Ltd v Corpcapital Bank Ltd [2006] SCA 1 (RSA) 50/2005

23 Feb
   
top