SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA

PIC

Judgments 2005

back

All documents are in pdf PDF format and require Acrobat Reader to open.

(*) Case Correction

  Citation & Summary
Delivered
137
Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Saunderson & Others 358/05
15-Dec
136
MG Phenithi v Minister of Education & Others 018/05
14-Dec
135
J Brown v MC Stone 489/05
08-Dec
134

P van Immerzeel v Santam Ltd 646/04

05-Dec
134

DPP Kwazulu-Natal v P 363/05

01-Dec
133

D Leibowitz t/a Lee Finance v AT Mhlana & Others 422/04

01-Dec
132
NEHAWU & IM Mathye v KE Tsatsi 062/05
01-Dec
131

NDPP v ME Parker 624/04

01-Dec
130

HM Ford v MGW Ford 052/05

01-Dec
129

M Dlamini & Another v PJ Josten & Others 030/05

30-Nov
128

SF Thugwana v RAF 530/04

30-Nov
127

A De Reszke v C Maras & Others 076/05

30-Nov
126

A Papagapiou v SAntam Limited 058/05

30-Nov
125
RS Napier v BP Barkhuizen 569/04
30-Nov
124
DPP v CE Olivier 042/05
30-Nov
123
SABC v FP Coop & Others 570/04
30-Nov
122
DL Ehlers & Others v Rand Water Board 484/04
30-Nov
121
JJ Steenkamp NO v Provincial Tender Board of the Eastern Cape 528/04
30-Nov
120
L Badenhorst v I Badenhorst 007/05
29-Nov
119

NS Mugwena v Minister of Safety & Security 303/03

29-Nov
118

F De Beer v Die Raad vir Gesondheidsberoepe van Suid-Afrika 600/04

29-Nov
117
Cell C (Pty) Ltd v GMB Zulu 593/04
29-Nov
116

Transnet Ltd & Another v SA Metal Machinery Co (Pty) Ltd 147/05

29-Nov
115
Government Employees Pension Fund v J Naidoo & S Naidoo 032/05
28-Nov
114

Rates Action Group v The City of Cape Town 016/05

25-Nov
113

TRC Hosking NO & Others v SA Coetzee NO & Others 499/04

25-Nov
112

Trustees for the Time Being of Two Oceans Aquarium Trust v Kantey & Templer (Pty) Ltd 545/04

25-Nov
111

The Public Servants Association v National Commissioner of the South African Police Service 573/04

25-Nov
110

ABSA Bank Ltd v TG Fraser; Portion 3 Lavianto CC 386/05

24-Nov
109
National Union of Mineworkers; Motlhoki & Others v Mazista Tiles (Pty) Ltd 507/04
23-Nov
108

International Marine Transport SA v MV "Le Cong" 080/05

23-Nov
107

M A Jacquesson v Minister of Finance 548/04

16-Nov
106

RAF v E van den Berg 019/05

16-Nov
105

TE Botha v Die Staat 562/04

15-Nov
104

C Mogale, Johnnic Publishing Ltd & NAP Publications, Allied Publishing Ltd v E Seima 575/04

14-Nov
103

MP Scheepers v The State 158/05

10-Nov
102

HA Klokow v MB Sullivan 410/04

29-Sep
101

Ethekwini Municipality v Verulam Medicentre (Pty) ltd 457/04

29-Sep
100

AB Nichol & Others v Registrar of Pension Funds & Others 467/04

29-Sep
99

MP King & Others v Attorneys Fidelity Fund Board of Control, Minister of Justice 561/04

29-Sep
98
Parsons Transport (Pty) Ltd v Global Insurance Co Ltd 345/04
29-Sep
97

S Prophet v NDPP 502/04

29-Sep
96

SA Breweries Ltd v P van Zyl 381/04

29-Sep
95

Navy Two CC v Industrial Zone Corporation 293/04

28-Sep
94

Gumede, RWM & Others v Subel SC, A NO & Others 429/04

27-Sep
93

Shoprite Checkers (EDMS) Bpk v LJJ Grobbelaar; DJM Heyns; PC Welgemoed 460/04

26-Sep
92

AF Dreyer NO; L Dreyer NO v AXZS Industries (Pty) Ltd 250/04

26-Sep
91

The Chairperson: Standing Tender Committee & Others v JFE Sapela Electronics (Pty) Ltd & Others 511/04

26-Sep
90

V & A Waterfront Properties (Pty) Ltd & Others v Helicopter & Marine Services (Pty) Ltd & Others 392/04

26-Sep
89
CT Buttner v CA Buttner 382/04
23-Sep
88

LUR, Vrystaat v M Louw, ML Louwrens 483/04

23-Sep
87

HA Wormald NO, Burton Queenstown CC, NK Baduza v LS Kambule 524/04

22-Sep
86

NW Mackay v EM Fey NO & MJ Lane NO 463/04

22-Sep
85

Dr HD Louwrens v JP Oldwage 181/04

21-Sep
84
Micro Finance Regulatory Council v AAA Investment (Pty) Ltd, Minister of Trade & Industry 346/04
21-Sep
83

JM Griffin & Others v The Master of the High Court & Others 446/04

19-Sep
82

SX Kimberley v The State 519/04

19-Sep
81
JJ Kemp, A Kemp, CF Muller, DJ Goosen v Dr JJH van Wyk, Minister van Landbou, Meat Industry Forum of SA 335/04
19-Sep
80

Maize Board v J Jackson 396/04

19-Sep
79

MEC for Agriculture ... v Sasol Oil (Pty) ltd & Others 368/04

16-Sep
78

City of Cape Town v WD Bourbon-Leftley NO & Others 415/04

15-Sep
77

Mzamba Taxi Owners' Association & Others v Bizana Yaxi Association & Others 358/04

09-Sep
76

Telimatrix (Pty) Ltd t/a Matrix Vehicle Tracking v Advertising Standards Authority SA 459/04

09-Sep
75

AM Moolla Group Ltd & Others v The Gap Inc & Others 123/04

09-Sep
74
PH Groenewald v The State 055/05
08-Sep
73

NW Erasmus v Die Staat 618/04

06-Sep
72

Liberty Investors Ltd v CSARS 353/04

30-Aug
71
MM Magida v The State 515/04
26-Aug
70

J Marx v Die Staat 397/04

23-Aug
69

Western Cape Min of Education & Others v Governing Body of Mikro Primary School & Others 140/05

27-Jun
68

RAF v M R Mtati obo Z Mtati 332/04

01-Jun
67

Media 24 Ltd, G Samuels v S Grobler 301/04

01-Jun
66

Transnet Ltd v L Rubenstein 238/04

01-Jun
65

Axiam Holdings Ltd v Deloitte & Touche 303/04

01-Jun
64

P May v The State 376/04

01-Jun
63

Gründlingh, Schüler, Turfsport CC v Phumelela Gaming and Leisure Ltd 152/04

01-Jun
62

Favish (also known as Shraga) Vidavsky v Body Corporate of Sunhill Villas 227/04

31-May
61
JMC Prinsloo, Botha Family Trust v Ndebele-Ndzundza Community 106/04
31-May
60
PJ Jansen v M Naylor, Atomaer (RSA) (Pty) Ltd, Atomaer Holdings (Pty) Ltd 251/04
31-May
59

M Naylor, Atomaer (RSA) (Pty) Ltd v PJ Jansen 243/04

31-May
58

P Liebenberg v The State 156/03

31-May
57

The CSARS v Stand Two Nine Nought Wynberg (Pty) Ltd, JF Klopper, Master of the High Court 324/04

31-May
56

The CSARS v Formalito (Pty) Ltd 328/04

31-May
55

Local Transitional Council of Delmas, Member of Executive Council for Local Government: Mpumalanga Province v WA Boshoff 302/04

31-May
54

CJ Maritz & CWC Pieterse v Maritz & Pieterse Incorporated 175/04

30-May
53

Privest Employee Solutions (Pty) Ltd v Vital Distribution Solutions (Pty) Ltd 126/04

30-May
52

Cordiant Trading CC v Daimler Chrysler Financial Services (debis) (Pty) Ltd 237/04

30-May
51

Gqwetha v Transkei Development Corporations Ltd, JLV Kwadjo, PR Vice 242/04

30-May
50

Constantia Insurance Company Ltd v Compusource 143/04

30-May
49

Medscheme Holdings v Bhamjee 214/04

27-May
48

SH Symington, J Durandt, F Rademan v Pretoria-Oos Privaat Hospitaal Bedryfs (Pty) Ltd 077/04

27-May
47

Eskom Holdings Ltd v JJ Hendricks obo JJ Hendricks 262/04

27-May
46

Nyathi v State 448/04

23-May
45

Maleka v State 408/04

20-May
44

Chipkin (Natal) Pty Ltd v Commissioner for SA Revenue Services 190/04

20-May
43

American Natural Soda Ash and Others v Competition Commission of SA and Others 554/03

13-May
42

Greys Marine Hout Bay and Others v Minister of Public Works and Others 347/04

13-May
41

Ndlovu v Santam 550/03

13-May
40

Cameron v State 199/04

11-May
39

National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa v Fry's Metals (Pty) Ltd 026/03

12-Apr
38

Commissioner for the SA Revenue Service v TFN Diamond Cutting Works 070/04

31-Mar
37

Moela v Shoniwe 054/04

31-Mar
36

Estate Agency Affairs Board v McLaggan 161/04

31-Mar
35

London Clubs International (Overseas) Investments (Pty) Ltd v Free State Gambling and Racing Board 525/03

31-Mar
34

Western Areas Limited v S 065/04

31-Mar
33

Private Security Industry Regulatory Authority v Association of Independent Contractors 127/04

31-Mar
32

Fraser v State 258/04

31-Mar
31

Road Accident Fund v Delport 183/04

31-Mar
30
SCOTT, FARLAM, CONRADIE, CLOETE et HEHER JJA 071/04
30-Mar
29

Northern Free State District Municipality v Matshai 090/04

30-Mar
28

Absa Bank Limited v Lombard 178/04

30-Mar
27

Hardaker v Phillips 120/04

30-Mar
26

Export Harness Supplies (Pty) Limited v Pasdec Automotive Technologies (Pty) Limited 097/04

29-Mar
25

Gauteng Gambling Board v Silverstar Development Limited 080/04

29-Mar
24

BOE Bank v City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality 240/03

29-Mar
23

S v Gentle 317/03

29-Mar
22

Aboo v Firstrand Bank Limited 319/04

29-Mar
21

Commissioner for South African Revenue Service v British Airways Plc 141/04

29-Mar
20

Naidoo v National Director of Public Prosecutions 062/04

29-Mar
19

African Bank Ltd v Weiner 051/04

29-Mar
18

Rhode v Stubbs 038/04

29-Mar
17

Land & Landbouontwikkelingsbank van Suid Afrika v Conradie 452/03

24-Mar
16

Clutchco (Pty) Ltd v Davis 035/04

24-Mar
15

Seven Eleven Corporation of SA (Pty) Ltd v Cancun Trading No 150 CC 108/04

24-Mar
14

Transvaal Agricultural Union v Minister of Agriculture and Land Affairs 091/03

23-Mar
13

Bay Centre Investments (Pty) Limited v Town Council of the Borough of Richards Bay 477/03

23-Mar
12

Distcor Export Partners v Director General of the Department of Trade and Industry 521/03

23-Mar
11

Littlewood v Minister of Home Affairs 160/04

22-Mar
10

Minister of Environmental Affairs v Scenematic Fourteen 085/04

22-Mar
9

Xaba v State 211/04

18-Mar
8
De Kock v S 244/04
18-Mar
7
The Unlawful Occupiers of the School Site v The City of Johannesburg 036/04
17-Mar
6
G L Ehlers NO and Others v H Graphorn and Others 265/03
15-Mar
5

Paarwater v South Sahara Investments (Pty) Ltd 091/04

03-Mar
4

Minister of Safety and Security v De Lima 063/04

03-Mar
3

Chabedi v State 497/04

03-Mar
2
SA Bank of Athens Limited v Van Zyl 431/03
21-Feb
1

Road Accident Fund v Makwetlane 649/02

17-Feb
   
top